Unlocking Student Potential with Prescriptive and Diagnostic Teaching

We’re excited to kick off the new year with a deep dive into a transformative approach to teaching, one that’s grounded in the knowledge of the student and anchored in the principles of Ortonian and Structured Literacy. We’re talking about The Art and Science of Prescriptive and Diagnostic Teaching, a powerful method that blends assessment, observation, and individualized instruction to meet students exactly where they are and help them succeed.

What Is Prescriptive and Diagnostic Teaching?

Prescriptive and diagnostic teaching is more than just a method; it’s a mindset that places the student at the center of instruction. This approach is especially effective for students with dyslexia or other learning differences, as it focuses on understanding a student’s learning profile and tailoring lessons to address their unique needs.

Teachers using this approach act as both diagnosticians and strategists. First, they assess students to pinpoint strengths and areas for growth. Then, they prescribe learning tasks in a structured, sequential manner to address specific gaps. Through observation and ongoing feedback, teachers refine these prescriptions to ensure continuous progress.

Why Does It Matter?

In education, no two students are exactly alike, and this is especially true for students who require intervention or dyslexia therapy. Diagnostic-prescriptive teaching allows educators to:

• Understand each student’s learning profile.
• Diagnose specific areas of need through assessments.
• Prescribe targeted lessons to address those needs.
• Continuously monitor and adjust instruction based on student progress.

As Reynolds and Fletcher-Janzen explain, diagnostic-prescriptive teaching is about matching instructional strategies to diagnostic patterns. It’s not about teaching to a test—it’s about equipping students with the tools they need to transfer knowledge across contexts and build independence.

What Does It Look Like in Practice?

Effective prescriptive and diagnostic teaching begins with assessment. Teachers use a combination of screening and diagnostic measures to evaluate foundational skills in literacy, such as phonics, handwriting, spelling, and reading fluency. For example:

• Screening Tools like DIBELS or Acadience can identify areas that need further exploration.
• Diagnostic Tools dig deeper into specific skills and reveal gaps in understanding.

Armed with this information, teachers design lessons that target identified needs. Let’s look at an example:

Scenario: A student struggles with fluency and punctuation, resulting in awkward phrasing and comprehension difficulties.

Diagnosis: The student doesn’t use punctuation effectively while reading.

Prescription:

1. Model proper phrasing and provide explicit instruction about what phrases mean.
2. Practice reading phrases using punctuation as visual cues.
3. Incorporate activities like "double-tapping" punctuation marks to reinforce awareness.
4. Create anchor charts showing how punctuation affects tone and phrasing.
5. Use phrase-cued texts to practice reading fluently with proper pauses and emphasis.

Through these steps, teachers help students address specific challenges while reinforcing broader literacy skills.

Teaching Older Students: Honoring Age While Addressing Gaps

Older students who struggle with foundational skills often need special consideration. They may have gaps in learning that are more pronounced than those of younger students. Teachers must balance addressing these gaps with age-appropriate strategies.

For example, if an older student struggles with spelling patterns, the teacher might:

• Assess phonics and spelling abilities.
• Prescribe lessons targeting word attack strategies.
• Use age-respectful materials that don’t feel remedial.
• Monitor progress closely and celebrate milestones to build confidence.

The Role of Progress Monitoring

Progress monitoring is a cornerstone of diagnostic-prescriptive teaching. Teachers gather data through informal assessments and observations to evaluate growth and determine next steps. This continuous cycle of test-teach-test ensures that instruction remains responsive and effective.

Tracking progress also gives students a sense of ownership. When they see tangible evidence of growth—whether it’s mastering letter-writing fluency (see Season 2, Episode 12 for more) or improving reading comprehension—they’re more motivated to keep going.

Building Confidence Through Structured Learning

Prescriptive and diagnostic teaching isn’t just about fixing weaknesses; it’s about leveraging strengths and building confidence. By providing clear goals, structured practice, and positive reinforcement, teachers help students experience success at every step.

The Gradual Release of Responsibility (GRR) model is particularly useful here. Teachers guide students through modeling, shared practice, and independent work, ensuring that learning is scaffolded and sustainable.

Final Thoughts

Diagnostic-prescriptive teaching is both an art and a science. It requires educators to blend knowledge, observation, and strategy to create personalized learning pathways for each student. While the process may seem complex, the rewards are immense—especially for students who struggle with learning differences.

Whether you’re new to this approach or looking to refine your practice, we invite you to explore more about diagnostic-prescriptive teaching in our podcast. Don’t miss Season 2, Episode 14 for a breakdown of formal educational evaluations and how they fit into this framework.

Let’s make this year one of growth and discovery for every learner!

For the full discussion, check out our latest episode of the Together in Literacy podcast. If you like what you hear, don’t forget to rate, leave a positive review, and subscribe!

We officially have merch! Show your love for the Together in Literacy podcast by sporting a t-shirt or sweatshirt!